For weeks now, I've been obsessing over which of two homes to buy. After pouring over the MLS listings for 6 months, and viewing many, many homes, I've narrowed it down to two distinct possibilities. I did take photos while I toured the homes, but apparently I could only use them for personal parusal, so instead, I will show you the published MLS listings (sorry for the not so great quality!).
I would so love your help and opinions on this! I'm at a complete loss with which to choose as they both offer pro's and con's.
Firstly, let me describe to you what we're looking for: A large home (minimum 4000 sq ft) on 1/2-2 acres (we love to garden), in a family friendly area, near great schools. I want something very similar in style to what you've seen on my blog, or something I can make into that style.
Option 1:
A lovely, large West Coast style home, built in 2004. It has delightful finishes, thick moldings, a nice layout, and is on 1/2 acre. It is in some need of basic maintenance, as the current owner is a single mom, and is overwhelmed by the size of the home and maintenance. It is 5500 sq ft (huge!), has 6 bedrooms, a theatre room, and many other great features. It is in a lovely, family friendly area: You know, the type of street where you just let your little ones out to play with all the neighbourhood kids.

Cons: Some maintenance issues (easily remedied by my handy hubby), and the kitchen does not have a lot of storage, and is in need of some major repair. For instance, I went to open a cupboard, and the drawer front came off. It is a lovely looking kitchen in pictures, but obviously made of cheap materials and in need of some tlc.
Also, the basement provides tons of room, but is a bit choppy feeling.
While the yard is 1/2 acre, we'll still be hardpressed to fit in our outdoor 'toys' such as our RV, garden impliments etc.
No shop for my hubby, and the garage is on the smaller end, so he would use one bay of the garage, but be quite pressed for space. While he says this doesn't bother him, he's coming from a home with a separate 600 sq ft shop and I think he'll really miss it.
HOME #2
This home was built in 2009. It features 4500 sq ft of high end space, with features such as air conditioning, 'green home' building standards, 1.43 acres of yard. It is a beautifully built home, on a gorgeous acreage featuring towering trees and a woodland feel. The neighbourhood is quite sought after, but is more of a private area, not particularly one where the kids all play together outside, but need to be driven to each others house to play.
Pro's: A large, very high end kitchen. Fabulous appliances, great layout and space, a professional gas range. Great storage space, a fabulous area for a craft/quilting room. Many high end building features. A huge, 3 bay garage with a workshop already in it.
Con's: While a gorgeous home, it is very contemporary in style. I despise the kitchen cab's, yet they are high end, very expensive solid walnut. Can I make this contemporary home into my cottage chic, frenchy space that I adore?
What would you do?? I would be incredibly appreciative of your ideas and opinions.
We are going on a second viewing of both homes in a few weeks, and would love to see them both, armed with your thoughts and opinions!